By Alan Caruba
I think if we were honest enough to
admit it, we are all bigoted in some way. Our gender or religion doesn’t really
qualify us as superior to anyone else, but we tend to fall back on these
identities and, consciously or not, assume they give us a reason to feel that we
are not only in possession of a special truth, but that it grants us the
privilege to feel better than others.
When we examine the issue of race,
however, the bigotry is inherent because racial groups are inclined to assign
superior characteristics to their own. It’s called human
nature.
There is something else “human” that
we need to address, over and above skin color, eye color, hair and other visible
differences.
“All human variants in DNA in all
people alive today trace their origins to countless common ancestors, all of
whom lived in Africa more than sixty thousand years ago. As humans, everyone is
related by common ancient ancestry, and ultimately, everyone is
African.”
That is
the message of a new book by Daniel J. Fairbanks, the dean of the College of
Science and Health at Utah Valley University, a distinguished research
geneticist and author. “Everyone is African: How Science Explodes the Myth of
Race” ($18.00. Prometheus Books, softcover). In a world where race is a
component of our lives, Fairbanks says, “Unfortunately, few people are aware of
how much is known about the genetic basis of race—or more accurately, the lack
thereof.”
“To many, the notion that race is
inherited seems self-evident. Yet extensive genetic research has demonstrated
that the genetic variation associated with what most people perceive as race
represents a small proportion of overall genetic variation. When viewed on a global scale, there are no
discrete genetic boundaries separating so-called races.”
It’s hard to argue with DNA, a
molecule that encodes the genetic instructions of all known living organisms.
Its scientific name is deoxyribonucleic acid and, along with proteins and
carbohydrates, it composes the three major macromolecules deemed essential for
all known forms of life. Most DNA molecules consist of two biopolymer stands
coiled around each other to form a double helix.
What we take to be “race” traces back
some one hundred thousand years ago when our species, humans, all lived in
Africa. Those early ancestors began to migrate from Africa eventually inhabiting
the entire globe. That makes the “human race” one
race.
So much evil has been done in the name
of race that much of our history and the world’s stems from the notion that the
variations, Caucasian, Negro, Asian, are determinative of various traits we
attribute to these and other “races.” If
we step back a bit, we will conclude we are talking about cultural differences, often the result
of geological differences. As Fairbanks notes, regarding the findings of DNA
research, “According to their estimates, people worldwide differ on average by
about 0.1 percent, evidence that all humans are genetically quite similar to one
another.”
It is hard, if not impossible, to
argue with the science involved. “The oldest remains of what anthropologists
call ‘anatomically modern humans’ (skeletons with features that resemble modern
humans) are exclusively from Africa, dating to about two hundred thousand years
ago. By contrast, the earliest remains of anatomically modern humans outside of
Africa thus far discovered are about one hundred thousand years old.”
The migration out of Africa is dated
to about sixty thousand to seventy thousand years ago “and their descendants,
through many generations, eventually populated the rest of the
world.”
Interestingly, but not surprisingly,
“most of the mutations that became variants affecting skin, eye, and hair
pigmentation happened outside of Africa in the distant descendants of people who
originally left Africa..” Those variations then spread through their descendants
within broad geographic regions.”
Those other people you see around you?
You are related to all of them.
© Alan Caruba, 2015
5 comments:
All living things have a common ancient ancestor, so long as you go back to the most ancient ancestor of all living things. That, however, does not negate the fact that there is a great deal of differentiation among kingdoms, phyla, ..., species, and races.
"Yet extensive genetic research has demonstrated that the genetic variation associated with what most people perceive as race represents a small proportion of overall genetic variation."
That just means that people vary in many other ways, not just race.
"When viewed on a global scale, there are no discrete genetic boundaries separating so-called races."
That would have to define the "genetic boundaries" term to be true or false. Given that genetic markers for races are identifiable (since they're mentioned in the previous sentence), one could define a "genetic boundary" consisting of partitioning based on those few markers, and bob's your uncle.
None of this is to justify bigotry or whatever.
"None of this is to justify bigotry or whatever."
Of course not.
I was merely responding to the facile remark, "As humans, everyone is related by common ancient ancestry, and ultimately, everyone is African.”
By analogy, "as humans, everyone is related by common ancient ancestry, and ultimately, everyone is also a single-celled microbe."
Great! This means I can get into Med School afterall!
Yes, but only if the med school is in Africa.
"Bigotry or whatever" may not be justified, but it's ubiquitous anyway. Because human (or microbe) nature.
Post a Comment